Skip to main content
South Harbour on Scalpay in the Outer Hebrides

The Outer Hebrides, an archipelago of 200 islands off Scotland’s northwest coast, are wind-scoured and rugged — bleak but at the same time beautiful in a haunting way. Growing up in Inverness, in the Scottish Highlands, I had heard much about Scalpay. My family is from Scalpay. My father was born there, and he and his family left when he was 5 years old.

To me, the island was like a fairy tale, an unknown land, far away on a distant planet, with stories of crofts, religion and herring fishing.

My Uncle David Morrison has lived his entire life on Gaelic-speaking Scalpay — Norse for “scallop island” — on the east side of the Outer Hebrides, about 35 miles from the Scottish coast. The island is just 4 kilometers long — one of 15 in the archipelago that are inhabited.

I first visited Scalpay several years ago to see my relatives and to see for myself where I had come from. When I arrived, I was told that there had been no births for seven years and that the fishing traditions and the people who had kept them alive were fading away, too. The last corner shop closed in 2007, along with the preschool. The island has no grade school or high school, either. Over the years, its population has shrunk to 250. A third of the islanders are pensioners. The rest cling tenaciously to fishing or crofts — small tenant farms — to earn a living in what most people would say is a harsh and unforgiving environment.

The corners of his eyes creased from squinting, Uncle David scans the gray waters of the North Atlantic, as he has just about every day since he was old enough to fish. And for a native of Scotland’s Outer Hebrides, that means for most of his 70 years. His face is as rugged as the island of his birth, and he still wakes around 5 o’clock in the morning five days a week to go down to Scalpay’s small harbor. There he meets up with Tappy, his longtime first mate, and together they go out to challenge the northern seas and net prawn on my uncle’s small fishing boat, Family Friend.

The corners of his eyes creased from squinting, Uncle David scans the gray waters of the North Atlantic.

Uncle David talks of the prawn fishing — hard, unpredictable, modest in its financial return — as a painful plummet from the 1960s and ’70s, when Scalpay’s fishermen were infected with “herring fever.” Back then, he ran the powerful ring-net fishing boat Hercules, which hauled in tons of “silver darlings,” as herring — a fish of legend and song — were called. The vessel would go to sea for days at a time and net my uncle and his six crewmembers a tidy profit.

In those halcyon times, villages such as Scalpay that had a strong fishing tradition thrived, while those that didn’t depend so much on the sea’s bounty declined. Before the stocks dwindled, the herring fishery supported not just the village economy, but also a way of life and a vibrant network of buyers, sellers, harvesters and processors, who forged a strong bond and formed a caring community that looked after one another.

The collapse of fishing — the traditional livelihood of many of Scalpay’s men — has led to the collapse of a way of life here and elsewhere around the world. These coastal and island communities can hardly sustain themselves as more and more young people leave their home and heritage to look for work. Dependent on the ocean and traditional fishing methods, they are being swallowed by the modern world.


Uncle David is not optimistic. “Far nach bi an-o’g cha bhi an sean,” he says, quoting a Gaelic adage that means, “If there is no young, there will be no old.”

On days when their boats are storm-bound at the docks, the fishermen who are left in Scalpay gather at my uncle’s house at 10 a.m. sharp for a “tea party,” a tradition that began decades ago. But instead of talking about their catches, they talk now about the good old days, when they could go out and come home with a hold full of silver darlings.

Yet when the weather is fair and the sea beckons, Uncle David and Tappy still motor out of Scalpay’s harbor on Family Friend to do what they’ve always done — the only thing they know how to do to earn a living. They fish.


Andy Mill went from chasing gold to chasing silver … tarpon that is.

Silver Obsession

Former world-class skier Andy Mill chases tarpon with as much fire as he once did Olympic gold

Diamond jigs are simple and effective.

The Perfect Lure

When fishing deep, it’s hard to beat these simple chrome-over-lead bruisers


A Last, Best Place

Inshore and offshore, Louisiana offers plenty of extraordinary fishing.


Edge Of The World

A group of women make the trip of a lifetime to fish Christmas Island


The Fall Run

My mind was unconsciously running through the 20 other places I would no doubt have been better off standing.

As two of his brothers watch, Mick Chivers lifts a bass caught the night before from the ice to a cleaning table.

Fishing For The Table

The evening began like a fishing daydream. The sun was dropping. The flooding tide and a cool wind were roughly aligned.


Spring Silver

You start your day hours before sunup, drive the dirt roads and rig in the dark, but the reward makes it worthwhile: hickory shad


Last of its Kind

With his three kids off to college, the boat is a little quieter and a little emptier. A father looks back on the years he spent with his most reliable fishing partners.

Snook sharpie Mike Thiels makes a 2 a.m. toss for bait from the Lantana Ocean Avenue Bridge in Florida

The Thump

Who answers the phone at 3:30 a.m., chats amiably, swaps helpful information, wishes the caller good luck but doesn’t go back to sleep humming a lullaby of curses?